Reading Response Rubric

Quality/Score	Quotations	Claim	Support
Excellent	A clear, explicit quotation is present with a reference to the chapter and section in Pragmatic Programmer.	A clear claim of agreement, disagreement, or a more nuanced opinion with regards to the validity or necessity of the quotation is present.	The claim is clearly justified through well reasoned supporting evidence and/or logic. The response shows evidence of critical thinking.
Good	A clear quotation is present with a reference to the chapter but not the section number.	The response discusses the quote in a fashion that expresses an overall opinion, but the opinion is not clearly stated.	Supporting arguments are given, but there may not be a clear and explicit connection between the arguments and precisely how they support the claim.
Tolerable	An idea from the text is paraphrased with a reference to the chapter from which it came.	-	Supporting arguments nebulously agree with the claim but are vague, wishy washy, or otherwise deliberately unclear.
Poor	It is unclear whether an idea was taken from the text or from where in the text it was taken.	The response takes no stand with respect to the given quote.	Supporting arguments for the claim are absent, tangential to the claim itself, or try only to further describe the quotation.

Updated Tue Sept. 20 2022, 15:45 by wsumner.